HS FOOTBALL SCOREBOARD
Friday’s Games:    Dover 32 New Philadelphia 28 FINAL / Indian Valley 7 Claymont 6 FINAL / Garaway 35 Ridgewood 34 FINAL / Newcomerstown 58 Buckeye Trail 7 FINAL / Strasburg 40 Tuscarawas Central Catholic 20 FINAL / Sandy Valley 51 Tusky Valley 48 FINAL / Fairless 28 Tuslaw 14 FINAL / Vienna Mathews 21 Conotton Valley 20 FINAL / East Canton 33 Malvern 12 FINAL / Carrollton 31 Minerva 10 FINAL / Harrison Central 68 Buckeye Local 14 FINAL      
menu Home
Local News

New Philadelphia arson suspect back in jail without bail

| January 23, 2026

NEW PHILADELPHIA – A New Philadelphia arson suspect who apparently missed a court date is now back in jail without bail.

Chance Cawley (TCSO)

Chance Cawley, 24, was indicted in December on four felony counts, including first-degree aggravated arson, for allegedly burning down a mobile home he had been evicted from on 11th Street NW in October. That fire spread to two neighboring homes and destroyed one of those, too. Nobody was hurt thanks to quick action by police and firefighters, according to New Philadelphia Police Chief Tessa Pohovey. She says officers fought through thick smoke to get residents out in one home, and firefighters rescued pets from another.

Cawley had posted a $10,000 surety bond on December 2nd but missed a January 6th arraignment hearing, according to court records.

Cawley was back in custody this week. He pleaded not guilty to the indictment.

Judge Michael Ernest revoked his earlier bond and ordered Cawley to go back to the Tuscarawas County Jail without bail to await further court proceedings.

A telephone pretrial is scheduled for Tuesday.

Written by