DESALES 23 – DOVER 16 (final)   |   MADISON COMPREHENSIVE 0 – NEW PHILADELPHIA 21 (final)   |   INDIAN VALLEY 0 – GARAWAY 17 (final)   |   CLAYMONT 35 – TUSKY VALLEY 0 (final)   |   TUSCARAWAS CENTRAL CATHOLIC 0  –  NEWCOMERSTOWN  30 (final) |   EAST CANTON 21 – STRASBURG 6 (final)   |   MALVERN 28 – BUCKEYE TRAIL 20 (final)   |   RIDGEWOOD 47 – SANDY VALLEY 30 (final)   |   WEST HOLMES 48 – LEXINGTON 14 (final)   |   CANTON SOUTH 39 – FAIRLESS 38 (final)   |   CONOTTON VALLEY 50 – FRONTIER 7
menu Home
Local News

Delays continue in trial of man accused of dumping body last fall

| August 10, 2022
Daniel Fitzgerald and public defender John Watters listen to judge Michael Ernest during a hearing in Tuscarawas County Common Pleas Court Tuesday.

NEW PHILADELPHIA (WJER) (August 10, 2022) – The case of a man accused of dumping a woman’s body in Goshen Township last October likely will continue for at least the next several weeks after he was assigned a new public defender.

Daniel Fitzgerald, 38, formerly of Akron, and his appointed public defender John Watters agreed to part ways at a pretrial hearing Tuesday.

Watters last week filed a motion to withdraw as counsel, alleging Fitzgerald screamed at his support staff. He said their relationship and communications have broken down beyond repair.

Fitzgerald in court Tuesday said he doesn’t trust Watters and called him trash.

“He don’t believe what I say,” Fitzgerald said.

Tuscarawas County Common Pleas Court Judge Michael Ernest granted Watters’s request to withdrawal and appointed Richard Drake out of Stark County to serve as Fitzgerald’s attorney.

A jury trial had been scheduled for next week, but Ernest says his goal now is to schedule a trial in four to six weeks.

Fitzgerald has pleaded not guilty to tampering with evidence, abuse of a corpse, and failure to report a death.

Prosecutors says he and Cekoyia Riechers dumped the body of Amber Sherrell along White Bridge Road near Route 416 after she died of a drug overdose at a home in Dover.

Riechers pleaded guilty to the charges and is scheduled to be sentenced later this month.

Fitzgerald is being held in Tuscarawas County Jail. He initially appeared via video for Tuesday’s hearing but then requested to appear in court in person.

Ernest delayed the hearing until the sheriff’s department transported Fitzgerald to the courthouse.

Written by